Bad RAC advice led to car virtually written-off - can I take action against them?

Yost72

New Member
Oct 19, 2010
1
0
0
Our VW Touran (reg 56, cost £8.5k 18 months ago) started making a horrendous noise on a dual carriageway a few weeks ago so we stopped the car and called the RAC. We were towed back home as the RAC man said he thought the turbo was about to go.

The next morning, another RAC person came to tow us to the nearest garage. He did not believe the turbo was about to go and believed it was just a loose pipe. He said it was fine to drive to the garage and he would follow behind. We did so, and halfway there the car seized up. We ended up being towed the rest of the way.

The garage advised that the car should never have been driven and that the RAC man was wrong to tell us to do so. Firstly, they said that as oil would have been draining from the engine due to the turbo problem, there was a real possibility of the car catching fire and secondly, as a result of it being driven there was also the possibility of long-term engine damage to the car.

6 weeks after having the new turbo fitted, we started hearing funny noises again, and we took it back to the garage who said that there is a problem with the engine, causing the turbo to keep breaking. The engine would need to be completely stripped to find the problem and the cost is prohibitive and they said we would be better off getting rid of the car now if we can.

They also said that there is a strong possibility this is linked to the fact that we were told to drive the car to the garage with the turbo problem.

Therefore, the questions I have are, a/ does all of the above sound correct from a technical perspective and b/ are we in a position to take any action against the RAC as we basically now have a car which is useless?

I know we cannot prove the direct link, but it is irrefutable that the RAC man gave us incorrect advice, so surely they at least have a case to answer?

Any assistance would be greatly appreciated. Thanks
 

nmonline

New Member
Oct 24, 2010
27
0
0
Hi, on the technical side, it sounds very feasible. Turbo's usually fail when they are starved of oil, or become clogged up with carbon deposits. If a turbo gives up, oil is consumed by the turbo which should be lubricating the engine. Also, fragments of the turbines can be dragged into the engine, causing serious damage. I believe you may have some recourse with the RAC, although I don't think you'll find it easy. Essentially, in my opinion, you pay your membership for them to provide a service, including technical advice, and I'm sure they have an obligation to minimise the risk of damage to your vehicle. The fact that you stopped your car before it stopped itself, and informed the 2nd recovery driver that the 1st one suggested turbo failure points to negligence. I would first thoroughly read the T's and C's of your subscription, then write a letter of complaint. Then see what they come back with.
 

ALewis

Moderator
Nov 23, 2010
691
4
0
South Wales
Also tO add to the advice above, if you are in a financial position , get an engineer to carry out a test and get a written report on what is wrong.
You can then use this against RAC , and if this does lead to small claims court / legal proceedings, this might potentially be able to be claimed back off RAC.
If you are not in a position to do so, get the garage owner / the mechanic who dealt with your car to put it down in writing what the problems are etc.